The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island - Boutique Hotel Review & Guide

The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island · Shelter Island · Rated 4.6/5 · From £200 per night

The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island is a boutique hotel in Shelter Island. This in-depth guide to The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island covers everything travellers need to know before booking, from rooms and amenities to the surrounding Shelter Island neighbourhood, nearby restaurants, and local attractions.

Located at 81 Shore Road, The Pridwin Hotel features private cottages and a pool. Relax at the full service spa or gym before dining on site. Book on ReelTrip.

Read on for our full review of The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island, what makes The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island stand out among hotels in Shelter Island, and how to book The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island directly through ReelTrip.

Travellers searching for a stay at The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island will find honest detail on rooms, dining, location, and value below. Whether you are visiting Shelter Island for business, a family break, or a weekend escape, this guide to The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island will help you decide if it is the right fit.

Photos of The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island

Browse the photo gallery below to get a feel for The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island, a boutique hotel in Shelter Island. Each image shows a different facet of The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island, from rooms and suites to communal spaces and the surrounding Shelter Island neighbourhood.

The Pridwin Hotel The Pridwin Hotel The Pridwin Hotel The Pridwin Hotel The Pridwin Hotel The Pridwin Hotel The Pridwin Hotel The Pridwin Hotel The Pridwin Hotel The Pridwin Hotel The Pridwin Hotel The Pridwin Hotel The Pridwin Hotel The Pridwin Hotel The Pridwin Hotel The Pridwin Hotel The Pridwin Hotel The Pridwin Hotel The Pridwin Hotel The Pridwin Hotel The Pridwin Hotel The Pridwin Hotel The Pridwin Hotel The Pridwin Hotel

About The Pridwin Hotel

About the property

Positioned on 81 Shore Road and overlooking Crescent Beach, The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island has occupied this prime stretch of coastline since 1927. The property functions as a seasonal retreat where the focus remains on the water and the wooded surroundings. Visitors arriving from the mainland via the North or South Ferry will find the hotel a short drive from the terminals, situated in a quiet corner of the island. Following a comprehensive renovation, the building maintains its historic profile while providing modern amenities like free WiFi and a refreshed fitness centre. As a standout choice among boutique hotels in Shelter Island, it balances the casual atmosphere of a summer camp with the refined service expected of a premium resort. The check in process is efficient, though guests should ensure they have photo identification ready as the check-in time and room readiness are subject to availability.

Rooms and suites

Accommodation at The Pridwin Hotel is divided between the main house and a collection of detached units. There are 33 guest rooms in the primary building, many of which offer views across the Peconic Bay. For those seeking more privacy or travelling with larger groups, the 16 private cottages provide separate living spaces and a distinct sense of seclusion under the trees. Each room is equipped with air conditioning and complimentary wireless internet access to ensure a comfortable stay. The decor avoids the clichés of nautical themes, instead opting for bright colours and functional, high quality furniture. Whether booking a standard double room or a larger suite, guests receive a booking confirmation with all necessary contact details provided for managing special requests. The layout of the cottages varies, with some featuring porches that face the water, making them a popular pick for those deciding where to stay in Shelter Island for an extended period.

Dining and bars

The culinary programme here focuses on classic American dishes that suit the coastal environment. The primary restaurant on site serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner, with a menu that highlights local seafood and seasonal produce sourced from the surrounding region. Tables are arranged to take advantage of the views, and the outdoor deck is a busy spot during the warmer months. Adjacent to the dining room, the bar lounge serves as a social hub where guests gather for drinks in the evening. The atmosphere is lively but never loud, fitting the relaxed pace of Shelter Island. For guests spending the day by the water, the service extends to the poolside area, ensuring refreshments are always available. It is recommended to communicate any dietary requirements or special requests at the time of booking or upon arrival to ensure the kitchen can accommodate them.

Location and setting

The setting on Shore Road places guests directly on the waterfront, providing immediate access to the beach and private docks. Shelter Island sits between the North and South Forks of Long Island, offering a slower pace than the neighbouring Hamptons. Exploring the area is best done by bicycle or car, as the island is home to extensive nature preserves and quiet residential lanes. The hotel provides a base from which to visit local farm stands or take the ferry over to Sag Harbor or Greenport for an afternoon. Being located in the us, specifically in New York State, the property experiences distinct seasons, with the summer months being the peak time for activity. The grounds are expansive, featuring green lawns that lead down to the shoreline, providing plenty of space for guests to find a quiet corner away from the main building.

Service and atmosphere

There is a distinct sense of tradition at The Pridwin Hotel that stems from its long history as a family oriented destination. The staff maintain a professional yet friendly presence, helping to coordinate activities such as paddleboarding, tennis, or trips to the spa. The spa facility includes a sauna and steam room, offering a space for recovery after a day spent outdoors. The gym is well equipped for those who wish to maintain their routine while away. Because this is a non smoking property, the air remains fresh, complementing the breeze coming off the bay. Policies regarding expected arrival time and check out are clearly defined, though the team tries to be flexible when possible. The overall vibe is one of understated quality, catering to those who appreciate a well run hotel without the need for excessive flashiness.

Why book here

Choosing The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island means opting for a piece of local history that has been carefully updated for the modern traveller. It remains one of the most reliable Shelter Island hotels for those who value a waterfront position and a full range of facilities. From the swimming pool and private beach access to the high standard of the on site dining, the property covers all the essentials of a coastal holiday in the us. The inclusion of a full service spa and a fitness centre ensures that even on rainy days, there are options for relaxation and activity. The combination of the historic main house and the standalone cottages allows for different types of stays, from romantic weekends to family gatherings. With its 4.6 guest rating, the property consistently delivers a high level of satisfaction. Secure your stay through ReelTrip to ensure your booking is handled efficiently, with all details and special requests managed before you arrive at this classic American resort.

Explore more in Shelter Island

Explore the area: Shelter Island travel guide.

The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island Vibes & Highlights

Below is a breakdown of the standout features and atmosphere that define The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island for travellers comparing it with other hotels in Shelter Island.

amenities at The Pridwin Hotel

  • Beachfront — Near the beach
  • Restaurant — On-site restaurant
  • Bar
  • Pool
  • Free WiFi — Complimentary WiFi
  • Spa
  • Gym

style at The Pridwin Hotel

  • Premium
  • Boutique — Boutique hotel experience

location at The Pridwin Hotel

  • United States
  • Shelter Island
  • us

Things to Know Before You Visit The Pridwin Hotel

Price and value

The cost of a stay at The Pridwin Hotel reflects its standing as a premium boutique property on the waterfront. Rates fluctuate significantly depending on the season, with peak summer weekends commanding the highest prices. While the hotel does not publicly list a flat rate, you can expect to pay a premium for the historical prestige and the private beach access. The value here is found in the extensive grounds and the inclusive feel of a traditional American resort. Pricing is often higher during July and August, but those visiting during the shoulder months of May or September will find the experience more cost effective without sacrificing the quality of the facilities. It is worth noting that certain activities or equipment hires may carry additional supplements, so it is wise to clarify these costs upon arrival.

Booking and check-in

Securing a room at The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island requires early planning, especially for the private cottages which are in high demand. The check-in time starts at 16:00, while guests are required to check out by 11:00. When you complete your reservation, ensure you review the contact details provided in your booking confirmation, as you may need to reach out to the front desk regarding your expected arrival time. Upon arrival, the reception team will require government-issued photo identification and a credit card for incidental charges. If you have specific needs regarding room placement or accessibility, you should submit your special requests at the time of booking, though these are always subject to availability and cannot be guaranteed in advance.

Location and getting here

Situated at 81 Shore Road, the hotel occupies a prime spot on the western shore of the island. Getting here involves a bit of a journey, as Shelter Island is only accessible by ferry. Most visitors arrive via the North Ferry from Greenport or the South Ferry from North Haven. If you are flying in, the nearest major hubs are John F. Kennedy International Airport or LaGuardia Airport in New York City, followed by a two to three-hour drive depending on traffic. Once you reach the island, the property is easy to find, sitting right on the water with views over Crescent Beach. The hotel provides a sense of isolation from the mainland bustle, making it a true retreat. While the island is small, having a car is beneficial for exploring the local nature preserves and various coastlines, though many guests choose to remain on the hotel grounds for the duration of their stay.

Rooms and family options

The accommodation at The Pridwin Hotel is split between 33 guest rooms in the main building and 16 private cottages. The guest rooms often feature a classic aesthetic, with many offering views of the water or the wooded grounds. For those travelling as a couple, a standard double room provides ample space, though those seeking more privacy should opt for the cottages. These detached units are particularly well suited for families or groups of friends who want a bit more room to spread out. The hotel maintains a non smoking policy across all indoor areas. If you are travelling with children, it is important to enquire about the extra bed policy before you arrive, as the layout of certain rooms may limit the ability to add rollaways or cots. The cottages offer a more residential feel, often featuring porches that are perfect for evening relaxation.

In-room amenities

The property ensures a comfortable stay by providing essential modern technology alongside its traditional charm. Guests can enjoy complimentary wireless internet access throughout the rooms and common areas, which is reliable enough for checking emails or streaming. Each room is equipped with air conditioning to manage the humid summer heat typical of the region. The bathrooms are stocked with high-quality toiletries and soft towels. While the focus here is on the natural surroundings and the beachfront, the rooms provide a quiet, cool space to retreat to after a day in the sun. You will not find overly complex gadgets, but the basics like free WiFi and comfortable bedding are well-executed. If you require specific items like an iron or extra pillows, the staff are generally quick to accommodate these needs through the front desk.

Dining, bar and breakfast

Dining at the hotel is a central part of the experience, with a restaurant on site that serves American classics with a focus on local seafood. The dining room is designed to take advantage of the water views, creating a bright atmosphere for breakfast and a more intimate setting for dinner. The bar lounge is a popular spot for both guests and locals, known for its lively environment and well-crafted cocktails. You can expect a menu that changes with the seasons, highlighting the produce found in the surrounding North Fork and Hamptons areas. While breakfast is available, it is worth checking your booking details to see if it is included or if additional charges apply. The outdoor deck is arguably the best place on Shelter Island for a sundowner, offering a panoramic view of the sunset over the bay.

Wellness, fitness and facilities

The Pridwin Hotel offers a robust selection of facilities for those who want to stay active or unwind. There is an outdoor pool which serves as a social hub during the day, surrounded by loungers for sunbathing. For physical activity, the gym and fitness centre provide enough equipment for a standard workout. The property also features a spa where guests can book treatments to relax. Being a beachfront property, much of the recreation revolves around the water; the hotel often provides access to kayaks or paddleboards. The grounds are expansive, offering plenty of space for lawn games or simply walking along the shoreline. For those who need to mix work with pleasure, the hotel can accommodate business needs, but the overall vibe is very much geared towards leisure and wellness.

Best time to visit

The peak season on Shelter Island runs from late June through to Labour Day in September. This is when the weather is warmest and all the hotel facilities are fully operational. However, the best time to visit for those who prefer a quieter experience is during the shoulder seasons. Late May and early June offer pleasant temperatures before the summer crowds arrive, while September provides warm water and a more relaxed atmosphere. During the height of summer, the island can become quite busy, and ferry wait times may increase. If you are looking for a peaceful retreat, the midweek periods in the spring or autumn are ideal. Many visitors find that the late afternoon light in the autumn is particularly beautiful against the Victorian architecture of the hotel.

Who it's best for and things to be aware of

This property is a fantastic choice for families seeking a traditional summer camp atmosphere with elevated comforts, as well as couples looking for a nostalgic waterfront getaway. The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island appeals to those who appreciate history and a slower pace of life. However, you should be aware that because this is a historic building, sound can sometimes travel between rooms, and the layout may include stairs that could be a challenge for those with mobility issues. The atmosphere is social and communal, particularly around the pool and bar. It is also important to remember that Shelter Island is relatively secluded, so if you crave high-energy nightlife or a wide variety of shopping malls, you might find the options here limited. This property is not ideal for travellers who require ultra-modern, minimalist high-tech environments.

Explore more in Shelter Island

Explore the area: Shelter Island travel guide.

Practical Information for The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island

Key contact details, check-in times, and useful facts for guests planning a stay at The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island.

Address: 81 Shore Road

Check-in time: 15:00:00

Check-out time: 11:00:00

About This Location

About the property

Positioned on 81 Shore Road and overlooking Crescent Beach, The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island has occupied this prime stretch of coastline since 1927. The property functions as a seasonal retreat where the focus remains on the water and the wooded surroundings. Visitors arriving from the mainland via the North or South Ferry will find the hotel a short drive from the terminals, situated in a quiet corner of the island. Following a comprehensive renovation, the building maintains its historic profile while providing modern amenities like free WiFi and a refreshed fitness centre. As a standout choice among boutique hotels in Shelter Island, it balances the casual atmosphere of a summer camp with the refined service expected of a premium resort. The check in process is efficient, though guests should ensure they have photo identification ready as the check-in time and room readiness are subject to availability.

Rooms and suites

Accommodation at The Pridwin Hotel is divided between the main house and a collection of detached units. There are 33 guest rooms in the primary building, many of which offer views across the Peconic Bay. For those seeking more privacy or travelling with larger groups, the 16 private cottages provide separate living spaces and a distinct sense of seclusion under the trees. Each room is equipped with air conditioning and complimentary wireless internet access to ensure a comfortable stay. The decor avoids the clichés of nautical themes, instead opting for bright colours and functional, high quality furniture. Whether booking a standard double room or a larger suite, guests receive a booking confirmation with all necessary contact details provided for managing special requests. The layout of the cottages varies, with some featuring porches that face the water, making them a popular pick for those deciding where to stay in Shelter Island for an extended period.

Dining and bars

The culinary programme here focuses on classic American dishes that suit the coastal environment. The primary restaurant on site serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner, with a menu that highlights local seafood and seasonal produce sourced from the surrounding region. Tables are arranged to take advantage of the views, and the outdoor deck is a busy spot during the warmer months. Adjacent to the dining room, the bar lounge serves as a social hub where guests gather for drinks in the evening. The atmosphere is lively but never loud, fitting the relaxed pace of Shelter Island. For guests spending the day by the water, the service extends to the poolside area, ensuring refreshments are always available. It is recommended to communicate any dietary requirements or special requests at the time of booking or upon arrival to ensure the kitchen can accommodate them.

Location and setting

The setting on Shore Road places guests directly on the waterfront, providing immediate access to the beach and private docks. Shelter Island sits between the North and South Forks of Long Island, offering a slower pace than the neighbouring Hamptons. Exploring the area is best done by bicycle or car, as the island is home to extensive nature preserves and quiet residential lanes. The hotel provides a base from which to visit local farm stands or take the ferry over to Sag Harbor or Greenport for an afternoon. Being located in the us, specifically in New York State, the property experiences distinct seasons, with the summer months being the peak time for activity. The grounds are expansive, featuring green lawns that lead down to the shoreline, providing plenty of space for guests to find a quiet corner away from the main building.

Service and atmosphere

There is a distinct sense of tradition at The Pridwin Hotel that stems from its long history as a family oriented destination. The staff maintain a professional yet friendly presence, helping to coordinate activities such as paddleboarding, tennis, or trips to the spa. The spa facility includes a sauna and steam room, offering a space for recovery after a day spent outdoors. The gym is well equipped for those who wish to maintain their routine while away. Because this is a non smoking property, the air remains fresh, complementing the breeze coming off the bay. Policies regarding expected arrival time and check out are clearly defined, though the team tries to be flexible when possible. The overall vibe is one of understated quality, catering to those who appreciate a well run hotel without the need for excessive flashiness.

Why book here

Choosing The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island means opting for a piece of local history that has been carefully updated for the modern traveller. It remains one of the most reliable Shelter Island hotels for those who value a waterfront position and a full range of facilities. From the swimming pool and private beach access to the high standard of the on site dining, the property covers all the essentials of a coastal holiday in the us. The inclusion of a full service spa and a fitness centre ensures that even on rainy days, there are options for relaxation and activity. The combination of the historic main house and the standalone cottages allows for different types of stays, from romantic weekends to family gatherings. With its 4.6 guest rating, the property consistently delivers a high level of satisfaction. Secure your stay through ReelTrip to ensure your booking is handled efficiently, with all details and special requests managed before you arrive at this classic American resort.

Explore more in Shelter Island

Explore the area: Shelter Island travel guide.

Frequently Asked Questions about The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island

Where is The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island located?

The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island is located at 81 Shore Road, in the heart of Shelter Island. The full address and directions to The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island can be found in the practical information section above.

How much does it cost to stay at The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island?

Rooms at The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island typically start from £200 per night, depending on the season, room type, and length of stay. Prices for The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island can rise during peak travel periods in Shelter Island.

What are the best things to do near The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island?

Guests staying at The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island are well placed for the top attractions in Shelter Island. The nearby restaurants and activities lists above show what is within easy walking distance of The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island.

Is The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island good for families?

The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island accommodates a range of travellers, including families. Check the rooms and family options section for specifics on family rooms and extra-bed policies at The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island.

How do I book The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island?

You can book The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island directly through ReelTrip using the booking link below. ReelTrip offers verified rates and real traveller video reviews for The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island.